Rich Pictures – Beyond the tipping point
ثبت نشده
چکیده
This paper concerns the interpretation of pictures which people draw in order to help them understand a situation – this includes critical and chronic situations such as those imagined in terms like: ‘the tipping point’. The pictures in question are called Rich Pictures (RPs) and the matter at the heart of interpretation is insight drawn from eduction (drawing forth). Insights relate to the individual, the group, the context in which the individual and the group find themselves, and the (often obscure or even hidden) means whereby the context can be changed or improved. In interpreting RPs groups and communities in difficult places we discover the history, variety and power of drawing. RP drawing, often as a collaborative exercise, is a powerful activity which has the capacity to break down barriers of language, education and culture. Drawing upon research with RPs from around the world and spanning over thirty years of our combined practice, this paper demonstrates RPs utility, universality and resilience. We argue that RP drawing enriches problem solving and, in the long term, saves time and resources from being expended on erroneous and/or superficial tasks. RPs embody the commonly expressed view that ‘pictures paint a thousand words’ but because of the collaborative nature of the style of drawing they actually go further than this by representing a thousand ideas. We argue that RPs are a powerful under-utilised tool which can be applied to make sense of a confusing world – they help us to explore complex and conflicted issues like the tipping point; one of the central themes of ISDRC 2015. To-date little effort has been made with regard to the comparative analysis of RPs between individuals and groups where they have been asked to address a common issue. Key questions surround how issues that are common across RP representations can be identified and ‘ranked’. This paper makes a case for RPs and sets out some thoughts and insights that we have had over the many years of working with them. To some extent the points we make are a ‘call’ to deeper and wider use; the setting of some frontiers that would warrant further research. For example we make the first case we are aware of for the application of techniques employed in ‘content analysis’ for assessing the meaning of multiple RPs. But we also want to talk about the relevance of RPs for a key theme of the ISDRC 2015 conference – the tipping point.
منابع مشابه
Halting the Climate Dominoes: Mitigation Policy Under Interacting Tipping Points
Scientific research highlights the possibility that man-made greenhouse gas emissions can trigger irreversible regime shifts in the climate system, so-called tipping points. The literature is particularly concerned with the possibility that a first regime shift, e.g., reinforcing the temperature response to emissions, significantly increases the likelihood of other tipping points, starting a do...
متن کاملStress on the Ward: Evidence of Safety Tipping Points in Hospitals
Do hospitals experience safety tipping points as utilization increases and, if so, what are the implications for hospital operations management? We argue that safety tipping points occur when managerial escalation policies are exhausted and workload variability buffers are depleted. Front-line clinical staff is forced to ration resources and, at the same time, becomes more error-prone as a resu...
متن کاملTowards a tipping point in responding to change: rising costs, fewer options for Arctic and global societies.
Climate change incurs costs, but government adaptation budgets are limited. Beyond a certain point, individuals must bear the costs or adapt to new circumstances, creating political-economic tipping points that we explore in three examples. First, many Alaska Native villages are threatened by erosion, but relocation is expensive. To date, critically threatened villages have not yet been relocat...
متن کاملEmergence of SARS-CoV-2 B.1.1.7 and the Future of Mega Sport Events: Is This the Tipping Point from Pandemic to Endemic?
No abstract as this is an Editorial
متن کاملOn the origin of planetary-scale tipping points.
Tipping points are recognised in many systems, including ecosystems and elements of the climate system. But can the biosphere as a whole tip and, if so, how? Past global tipping points were rare and occurred in the coupled planetary-scale dynamics of the Earth system, not in the local-scale dynamics of its weakly interacting component ecosystems. Yet, evolutionary innovations have triggered pas...
متن کامل